slug.com slug.com
5 3

Fines for Miscarriages

JacksonNought 8 May 28
Share
You must be a member of this group before commenting. Join Group

Be part of the movement!

Welcome to the community for those who value free speech, evidence and civil discourse.

Create your free account

5 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

1

The above claim has been largely debunked, and even Snopes has determined that claim to be mostly false-
[snopes.com]

What's True:
The bill could greatly expand the obligation on healthcare providers to file fetal death certificates. In order to fully discharge that legal obligation, healthcare providers would, in many cases, have to consult with patients about the details of the fetal death, even if the patients would strongly prefer not to discuss fetal death certificates and similar considerations. Thus, the bill was likely to multiply the trauma suffered by patients who undergo an abortion or miscarriage in Pennsylvania.

What's False:
However, Pennsylvania law does not require patients themselves to register fetal deaths, or file, obtain or pay for a fetal death certificate, and it does not fine them for having a miscarriage. The bill would not introduce such legal requirements.

This is another classic example of why I don't trust either political extreme, and the left have their share of conspiracy theories just like the right does. Lastly, I am personally opposed to House Bill 118 of 2021, as Pennsylvania already has enough restrictions on abortions in place and said restrictions have done little to curb abortion procedures, so more of the same would be pointless.

0

does this also need to be done for abortions, as miscarry is a natural spontaneous abortion

KeVince Level 8 May 29, 2021
0

If you're going to go down this sort of road, you shouldn't make it so easy to refute, unless you get participation points from comments---I'm still trying to figure out how that one works.

2

So I'm struggling a little with this person's characterization for two reasons:

One, the medical professional is the one who fills out the death certificate, so I'm not clear where the whole "force [the woman] to fill out this form" comes from.

Two, having read HB118, I did not see anything to suggest that the legislature voted to "fine women who miscarry." The only costs I even see mentioned are if the woman chooses to have the remains disposed of in a manner that goes beyond "usual and customary."

So what am I missing here?

The bill requires all fetal deaths to have a death certificate, including miscarriages. It also charges the woman $20 to pay for this certificate. So it fines women $20 for having a miscarriage.

@JacksonNought

That's a bit of a reach, don't you think? By that argument, you may as well say that requiring the woman to pay for any part of the medical procedure is "fining" her.

@JacksonNought

Van you point to that 20 dollar language, and it being universal in apllcation?

@govols

Well, to be fair Google search does confirm that PA fetal death certificates are $20. But I still think that characterizing it as a fine is emotionally manipulative twaddle.

@Alysandir Typical leftist garbage from JasonZero.

@Rick-A

Perhaps. But I have no interest in attacking the man, only debating the arguments.

We SHOULD want @JacksonNought to challenge our beliefs, otherwise this place just becomes another echo chamber. I may not like his message and I may occasionally frown at his tactics, but I appreciate what he does.

@Alysandir I don't.

3

I have suspicions somebody is lying by ommission.

govols Level 8 May 28, 2021

Sometimes you HAVE to look at the messenger...

Or you could do your own research and verify...

[aclupa.org]

@JacksonNought
Or you could..

[legis.state.pa.us]

@JacksonNought

You might link the actual bill rather than a biased summary as you suggest doing ones own research.

@govols or link the actual bill, not a memo from 2020.

[legis.state.pa.us]

@JacksonNought

So, the actual bill is currently removed from consideration?

@govols This could be a set up folks, don’t say anything nasty about JasonZero you might get a “cancel”. I got a 5 day suspension for defending the unborn in a heated conversation under similar conditions. I am not implying anything here.

Write Comment

Recent Visitors 29

Photos 11,808 More

Posted by JohnHoukAn Intro to Dr.

Posted by JohnHoukDO NOT Allow Medical Tyranny to Continue – Refresher Videos Pt.

Posted by Weltansicht....and oppossums eat all the ticks....

Posted by JohnHoukAmerican Intel Spies & Withholds Info from Trump! WAKE UP AMERICANS! SUMMARY: Americans who still support The Democratic Party (which should be re-labeled Dem-Marxist Party) are supporting spying ...

Posted by FocusOn1Clown world: when people cant figure their shit out, they run to a woman who says she doesnt know what a woman is and wears a black robe for guidance.

Posted by Sensrhim4hizvewzHow quickly it all turned.

Posted by Sensrhim4hizvewzMuh Diversity...

Posted by JohnHoukAn Intro to THE EXPOSÉ Look at Occult Influence on Elitists SUMMARY: THE EXPOSÉ has delved into a Substack post by Elizabeth Nickson … I am unsure if THE EXPOSÉ had this in mind, but my take ...

Posted by FocusOn1An0maly on facebook.... Communists violating the first amendment in america

Posted by JohnHoukAntisemitism Idiocy Summary: I have not seen the coverage of college campus protests supporting the Hamas butchers as Israel has entered Gaza to punish pseudo-Palestinians for the 10/7/23 genocide ...

Posted by JohnHoukAI Dystopia Moving from Sci-Fi to a WEF NWO: A Look at Stop World Control Documentary, ‘THE END OF HUMANITY - As Planned By The Global Leaders’ SUMMARY: An intro by Patricia Harrity followed ...

Posted by JohnHoukGlobalist Tyranny Videos Batch – Part TWO SUMMARY: The video list I’m sharing leans more toward Globalist Tyranny (which includes the American traitors – the Dem-Marxists) in this batch.

Posted by JohnHoukGlobalist Tyranny Videos Batch – Part ONE SUMMARY: I’ve spent the last few days looking at saved videos largely from Telegram Social Media.

Posted by JohnHoukWATCH OUT FOR AN AI TYRANNY & NSA Spying SUMMARY: I’ve witnessed too many dark-side leaps and bounds to give credence to AI-Tyranny naysayers.

Posted by Sensrhim4hizvewzCohencidence or PLANNED???

Posted by Sensrhim4hizvewz Hopefully, everyone catches it and everyone gets better

  • Top tags#video #youtube #world #government #media #biden #democrats #USA #truth #children #Police #society #god #money #reason #Canada #rights #freedom #culture #China #hope #racist #death #vote #politics #communist #evil #socialist #Socialism #TheTruth #justice #kids #democrat #evidence #crime #conservative #hell #laws #nation #federal #liberal #community #racism #military #climate #violence #book #politicians #fear #joebiden ...

    Members 9,403Top

    Moderators