slug.com slug.com
50 8

Why do many Leftists fervently believe Trump is a reincarnation of Hitler?

One of the laws of online discussions is that the longer it goes, eventually someone will make a comparison involving Nazis or Hilter (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godwin%27s_law). This seems most accurate when Leftists think about Trump... an example from the NYTimes today: [nytimes.com]

While it is true that Trump has a reputation for invoking patriotism, it is unclear if his actions as president is a "lurch toward authoritarianism". In the 1930s, Hitler moved to censor the press, organized boycotts of businesses run by those he didn't like, created a state religion of hate towards what he claimed were an oppressive group, tightly controlled arts (films had to have ideological messaging) and education (e.g., school age books to Indoctrinate hate towards a group), and promoted a chosen group as morally superior to the oppressive group. Could it be argued that these actions are more what we're seeing from the Left?

Leftists invoke Hitler comparisons to Trump based on...

  • 7 votes
  • 17 votes
  • 2 votes
  • 7 votes
  • 1 vote
  • 3 votes
  • 2 votes
  • 22 votes
Admin 8 July 26
Share
You must be a member of this group before commenting. Join Group

Be part of the movement!

Welcome to the community for those who value free speech, evidence and civil discourse.

Create your free account

50 comments

Feel free to reply to any comment by clicking the "Reply" button.

3

They listen to what the mainstream medias have to say on the topic, and automatically believe such.

13

Ironic part is, with the woke mentality the left has become far more fascist in their approach than most of those on the right ever could be.

The left accuses President Trump of “inciting” or “encouraging” violence while they’re out in the streets actually Burning Looting Murdering. They accuse him of oppressing people while they endorse brands and regimes that actually employ slave labor. They call him a racist but actively try to have peoples lives ruined for saying “white lives matter.” They call him a sexist while they support candidates who’ve been CREDIBLY accused of sexual assault. They call him a homophobe while they support people who hurl homosexuals off of rooftops.. the projection goes on and on and on. Shit is comedy! I’m no President Trump nutswinger.. he’s done plenty of shit that I don’t agree with, and has disappointed the hell out of me on several occasions, but the left’s hypocrisy is.. laughable, meng

@tonkotsu Couldn't agree with you more on that, the hypocrisy from the left is astounding.

3

Laziness

Always a sign of a lack of knowledge. The political equivalent of dropping an “F” bomb. Maximum attention, minimum vocabulary.

2

I fear we're moving closer & closer to Berlin circa 1938. Part of my psyche is troubled. Part of my psyche is proud. But.... when will the checks & balances of our constitutional republic kick in?

Could you elaborate a bit what you mean by "Berlin circa 1938"? Are you more concerned that Trump or the Leftists are "Hitler"? I wonder how would Hitler handle the protests of 2020...

Certainly trying times we live in...

@Admin With bullets.

@Admin
First the caveat: I'm no historian or expert on Germany.
Around 1938, Germany was in a depression, still recovering from The Great War. Unemployment was . The traditional government had been unable to address reconstruction of the country. Infrastructure was falling apart, and general unrest, crime, and poverty were rampant. Along comes a firebrand who latches on to the National Socialist party. Through demagoguery, a strong appeal to nationalistic pride & promises of making Deutschland great again, he is elected to power. He creates his own police group <Brown Shirts> and rebuilds the military for nationalistic purposes. Germany then falls under the spell of Nazism.

Sounds familiar to me.
Now, I voted for President Trump. And if Mr. Biden is the nominee for the Democrats, I may have to sit this one out.

12

It's not solely about Trump. It could be anyone they want to destroy.

5

They compare him to Hitler because if people are focused on Trump and the idea that he's a nazi they won't notice that the people they're following are the real fascists and who they should actually be afraid of.

Lilu Level 5 July 26, 2020

America needs actual Nationalism. Perhaps this time the Jews won't be rounded up.

1

Do you bring this up in the context of his recent legal boundary pushing? Trump is a lazy, self-interested authoritarian. Leftists admit that many of his policies are not new or shocking but a continuation of the bipartisan consensus of recent decades. What alarms them is the boundary pushing with immigrants, with the Census, in Washington, DC, in Portland, and possibly in cities throughout the country, combined with the open desire of at least 30% of the population for a civil war to cleanse the country of leftists, liberals, and minorities.

I friend of mine forwarded me the NYTimes article as she's afraid that Trump is ratcheting up authoritarianism... so I made this the topic of the day. My personal belief is fear on both sides is due to outrage culture and social media training us to dehumanize those who have different views. I often hear both sides saying that the other side is the one doing bad things and they're just responding. Reminds me of a kid pulling the hair of another kid and saying, "I'm not pulling, you are!". As these protests lose their novelty, the protestors seem to raise the stakes and, after being on sidelines, Trump is (reluctantly?) getting the Federal government involved... which raises things more. My liberal friends seem both afraid of the things that my conservative friends fear but in reverse. I'm just trying to make sense of it.

2

The Left have degraded to almost pure emotional language, Pathos, of which Hitler is the ultimate emotive cudgel . Given Trumps willingness to punch back or even regularly resort to ridicule and mockery they got to Hitler a lot faster.

10

The real facts are that the left does not hate Trump. They Hate you. They hate that beautiful straight normal All- American family of his and your family if you are anything like Trumps family and if you are white they hate you even more. IT is an irrational psychosis of those who hate themselves at bottom because they are not like you and his family.
"Socialism is the hatred of the other guy who is having a better time in the world" - The icon bard of American Journalism - H.L. Mencken

I agree. thumbs up

Totally agree. I’d add that the left also doesn’t care about the black community, immigrants, gays, or the climate. The exploit these issues to advance their own agenda: power.

"normal All- American family of his"

His normal family of having children with three separate wives, all of whom he cheated on? All-American family, when his first wife was an immigrant from Czechia and his current wife is an immigrant from Slovenia? I wonder, would you also consider the Obamas a normal all-American family, having all been born in the USA and being happily married for 28 years with no sex scandals?

@JacksonNought Marriages lead to- or away from -but are not the same thing as- family.

@JacksonNought Obama did have sex scandals, btw. Lots of rumors of him being a closeted gay man with several men mentioned by name. Not that I would have given a shit. If someone's wife doesn't care then I don't care. My issue was that as president he was less like Senator Obama and more like President George Bush. I wasn't down with that whole droning kids and militarizing the police thing.

How is an immigrant wife not "All American"? As one myself I was always under the impression that this was quintessentially American. Hence the whole Immigration and Naturalization Department--it seals the deal on being an American.

That's exactly true. The fact that Hilter is used is a scare tactic. But most my age (41) didn't take history or only believe the history they were taught.

@ThomasinaPaine

I don't like to make blanket statements or generalities, but I since the OP decided to do so and basically claim "the left hates you especially if you are white"...

I have nothing wrong with immigrants, but it is odd for a group ("the right" ) who is extremely family values and conservative Christian and nationalistic and anti-immigration, to then champion a man who cheated on every wife and who has married two immigrants as "all-American" and claim them to be the epitome of "normal". And then many on the right, who champion Trump's family, would go out of their way to blast Obama's family as not-normal or not-American. I really am just calling out the hypocrisy here.

And Obama did not have sex scandals. Q-level nutjob conspiracy theories about Obama being gay or Michelle being a man doesn't equal actual scandals. There is also the pee-tape rumor about Trump, with Russia controlling him through blackmail of the tape - would you consider that a real scandal?

I wasn't a big fan of Obama for the same reasons as you, with the drones and militarization and punishing whistle-blowers... but I would certainly consider their family normal Americans, and I would not agree that "the left hates your normal family".

@JacksonNought This isn't the 90's. If we're generalizing I'd say that the right isn't all Christian Coalition anymore. In fact, the only really outward Praise Jesus Christians that you see tend to be people of color. My black friends are all "Bless!" and "Amen!" and "Satan is a liar" while my white Christian friends have COEXIST bumperstickers and wear Pride flag pins.

I know people who worked in the Obama White House so I'll just say that I disagree and that my opinion of Michelle is 10x higher than her husband. Michelle, I still like. Him...not in the least.

I also don't agree on the left doesn't hate normal families. The left hates everyone today especially lesbian and bisexual women. As it does not seem that you are one of those you probably don't understand the doxxing, rape threats, death threats and daily harassment from the left towards women who don't want a "lady penis". Watch Arielle Scarcella sometime and or Google "Kill all Terfs" then look at the images in the search.

There is a reason we are in a mass exodus the fuck outta progressiveville. At least when the right tried conversion therapy there was grape juice and cookies. The left's version include "rape bats" and doxxing.

@ThomasinaPaine There are literal sexual predator men dressed as women reading stories to school children in schools. There are 10 year old boys who identify as gau stripping for men. Homosexuality and degeneracy is openly embraced by the media. There are huge gay pride parades. Kids are now able to transition from being male to female even if one parent does not want that, the state forces it. Gays can get married. Every GD TV show has gays in it. Gay propaganda is showing up in cartoons and on classrooms. Gays even have hate crime statutes protecting them from violence. It goes on and on and on from there. The left, the liberals, the Marxists, the Democrats (except for blacks) seem to support the gay agenda being foisted upon the American people.

3

Leftists A
Those who conspire to create, produce, and propagate the false Marxists/Communist narrative:

Leftists A invoke Hitler comparisons to Trump based on careful study of the feedback data and timing for effect in order to maximize the transfer of power from those who produce anything worth stealing to those who steal it with the Marxist/Communist Treasonous Crime Spree.

Leftists B
Those who believe the false Marxists/Communist narrative or are paid to propagate it:

Leftists B invoke Hitler comparisons to Trump because they are told to do so, and they obey without question like good little Nazis.

1

Because Hitler was white they use this as a perfect excuse to try to extrapolate the idea that whites are bad and evil when the truth is that there would be no civilization without them. Of course they hate civilization because they would prefer the law of tooth and claw with no law so that they could then have anarchy and might makes right instead of civilization. Kind of the exact way Hitler thought. This way they could steal what you have, have any type and variety of sex they might like and make life miserable for you and your family. Same stuff communist have always done under other excuses for a better world that is in reality always worse. Red China and Soviet Russia come to mind for starters.

9

The comparison has nothing to do with Trump, it’s a typical, over-the-top, leftist smear that’s lost meaning through overuse.

The comparison to WWII Germans was absolutely shocking when progressives first used it against Israelis, because Jews were the victims of the Berlin regime. Today, it’s repeated so often it’s lost much of it punch.

As soon as someone drags out this tired go-to in conversation, I know the person using it has limited knowledge and/or a limited vocabulary.

GeeMac Level 8 July 26, 2020
1

Thanks to the influence of people of a certain hat size, they have been taught that Hitler and the NS were the worst people in world history, so "Hitler" or "Nazi" is the strongest insult they can think of. It doesn't make any sense if you look at it any deeper than that; of course they would agree with many of the National Socialists' ideas themselves.

2

What is really interesting is that the left may cause the rise of a real Hitler type in this country. Believe me, Trump is a powder puff in comparison. The left used to always call conservatives reactionary and they are as a reaction to the left same as Hitler was. See German History pre WWII...very similar to what is going on here today.

1

The left always accuses their rivals of what they're guilty of themselves.

shortd Level 1 July 26, 2020

And the right does not?

3

A generation raised without being taught the virtue of emotional discipline will see anyone trying to impose order as authoritarian. If your primary personality traits are openness and empathy you will view conscientiouness as authoritarian. The troubling aspect is that conscientiousness is a measure of maturity.

It cannot be said often enough there is no such thing as emotional intelligence. Emotions are instincts, instincts incompatible with the harsh realities of civilized life that require stability. That said there is an optional level of instability just as mutations are necessary for physical evolution. That is not to say that by design is undesirable only that most ideas like mutations have negative consequences that are difficult to predict. Societies are complex chaotic systems that should be tinkered with caution.

One of the things the left and I would argue emotionally oriented conservatives hate about Trump is his apparent lack of empathy. The problem is empathy like the instinct for fairness evolved to increase fitness in a easy but unstable environment. An environment where networking not competence determine placement in the social hierarchy. For those oriented towards those instincts competency itself can be seen as authoritarian.

The finally piece of the puzzle is that people have been inculcalated by science with a misunderstanding of determinism. Most of empiricism, especially as it pertains to complex chaotic systems, is probabilistic. I'm environments that are irreducible problem solving becomes a matter of close enough. The same process that inculcalated people with a misunderstanding of determinism reinforces the instinct for right and wrong, fight or flight. From a naturalistic perspective you can't be partially alive or somewhat pregnant. But we do not live in a natural world (ignoring the fact that what is not natural doesn't technically exist). We live in a civilized world of abstractions. Abstraction that are real but do not have physical existence but do impact how we live in the physical world. One of those abstraction is freewill.

Without freewill moral agency is impossible. Of course freewill doesn't actually exist it is an abstraction. A social construct that allows for moral agency and personal responsibility. All complex social animals have some degree of freewill but that is a topic for another day. In a complex society freewill forms the basis for rewards and punishment. Rewards an punishment according to rules not the primitive instincts for empathy and fairness. The fact that those instincts must be satisfied in a highly functional society is a reflection that we are apes not ants. You have to understand that complexity means that empathy and fairness becomes a question of for whom. For the most part the question is unanswerable and we have to settle for equal application of the rules which leaves people who are emotionally or instinctually oriented feeling the rules are authoritarian.

wolfhnd Level 8 July 26, 2020
5

...their lack of understanding of history and their desire to obfuscate their tyrannical desires for totalitarianism and their attempt to overthrow the U.S. Constitution.

Facci Level 7 July 26, 2020
0

Because the left always project to push their agendas.

2

How about all of the above?

How is it any different than Republicans comparing Obama to Hitler, or saying wearing a thin piece of cloth over your face during a pandemic is akin to Nazi concentration camps?

Of course there are several people on this site who hate Jews and idolize Hitler, and would happily compare Trump to Hitler as if it was a positive thing.

Sad but true...

0

They see him as an evil RW Capitalist...
That's enough for LW numpties to make the comparison.

3

Hitler is the great demon of the twentieth century. His crimes against humanity are not so monumental perhaps as those of Stalin, Mao and Pol Pot but his image and his Hugo Boss style have given him a presence that outshines that of the others. So it is only natural that Leftists would choose him for comparison to condemn President Trump. The Right did the same with President Obama though it was not such a natural response. Hitler was an enemy of Communism and the Left is as close to Communism as we have seen in this country. However the alleged censoring of the press and social media is simply projection. To complain and condemn is not the same as censorship; cancellation, however, is.

Great point. I believe the stats from the 20th Century show 70-million killed by fascism and 100-million killed by communism. So Stalin and Mao have more blood on their hands. But the last few generations have zero knowledge of history, so they proudly wear Che Guevara tee shirts and talk about the wonders of socialism.

3

Which non-Democrat hasn't the left called or compared to Hitler? Over politics no less. It's their 'go to' line.

It’s completely out of control. It’s was remarkable to watch the Democratic debates and see the candidates attack each other with ridiculous charges. Kamala Harris accusing Joe Biden of racism, and Pete Buttigieg attacked by Elizabeth Warren as being owned by billionaires. If the Dems think their own candidates are racist, no wonder they are completely unhinged when they talk about Trump.

@GeeMac You might want to go back and look at the Republican debates in 2016.

@Pand0ro why?

@GeeMac I don't know. Maybe there was some interparty bashing going on.

@Pand0ro Oh, no doubt, all politicians bash the hell out of each other, even within their own parties. That wasn’t my point. I’m saying no wonder the Dems think Trump is a racist, that’s exactly how the Dems view each other.

@GeeMac I am a racist. I don't want to be, I try not to be but when circumstances come together I find myself disparaging blacks, Arabs, Chinese, Japanese, etc. solely based on their race. It is part of our inbuilt instincts to favor our group. Are Democrats in such disarray? They have always been in disarray, it is one of the defining features of being a Democrat. Many Democrats think that being a Republican makes them automatically racist while not recognizing the racism in themselves. The interbashing in the Democratic debates is no different that that in the Republican debates.

@Pand0ro I have to give you top marks for honesty. You’re actually far more honest that Kamala Harris when she made her racist smear against Sleepy Joe.

Kamala makes a living hating people like you: racists. She doesn’t believe for a second that Sleepy Joe is a racist. She smeared him to garner points. It was totally fake. That’s where Dems differ from Republicans, I think. When Jeb Bush attacked Trump as an asshole, he was being honest, and to some degree, correct. When Trump called Bush a low energy loser, and pointed out 911 happened on his brother George W watch, he was being 100% truthful and sincere.

Not like Kamala, who is just a liar. That’s the difference.

@GeeMac I have voted mostly Democratic since I was 21 yrs old. Democrats can be very contrived in their self-presentation because so many Democrats are all over the place politically and unlike Republicans, do not feel compelled to stick to the party line. The far left with its antifa movement, cancel culture, political correctness and believing that there is no differences between sexes and intellectual ability among people are living in a fantasy world. That being said the far right are living in a fantasy world thinking that all we have to do is get rid of all Democrats and we will be living in utopia. I do believe Trump is completely incompetent as president (I am also) and has created chaos in the government. Given the loyalty that is valued in the Republican party, the fact that the Lincoln Project formed is astounding to me. Someone has to be unbelievably unfit to have that happen. Rex Tillerson of all people called him "a f***ing moron". Both parties have their serious problems and no party ever formed will be without faults. People should be loyal to their country over their party.

@Pand0ro absolutely no doubt Trump can be his own worst enemy. But I I’d vote for him over Biden, or Kamila, or Cory Booker or Jay Inslee any day. I can’t think of a single Democrat who isn’t towing the woke progressive line.

The Republicans play to a base that embraces flag, faith and family. They are failing miserably at communicating why those values matter in 2020.

The Democrats increasing play to an entitled, morally snobbish base that hates everything the US stands for. And they continue to dismantle America, piece by painful piece.

@GeeMac The far left's madness has forgotten there is a nation that needs leadership that covers the needs of the country, not the few. They should be concentrating on the massive redistribution of wealth from the many to the few, working at making sure families are able to make a reasonable living and the failing infrastructure. Republicans PLAY to a flag, faith and family base but really don't care about it except in the ways that gains them votes. They are trying to make America a one-party state where they work with the billionaires to control all the money and power. Guess we're stuck between a rock and a hard place.

2

The Left has been very 'liberal' about bestowing fascist accusations on their opponents. The ashes of WWII were barely cool when Harry Truman called Dewey and Republicans "front men for fascists."

Eisenhower escaped this accusation. He was, after all, the leader of the armies that crushed fascism.

Every other Republican president has been excoriated as a racist, fascist warmonger, and (inevitably) Hitler-like. There was a peak of vituperation with Nixon (Vietnam War and Watergate). There was another with George W. Bush (Iraq War) and today's raging creshendo with Trump.

It is certainly the tendency for each party to demonize the other. Republicans are referred to as Facist by the left and Democrats as Communists and Socialists by the right. If Eisenhower were running for office today he would be considered a leftist. He is a general who cautioned us about the military-industrial complex. Nixon did not start the Vietnam war, he is the one who got us out of it. Dick Cheney when he was Secretary of Defense for HW was asked why HW did not go in and take over Iraq when he had the chance. Mr. Cheney said we would be caught up in a quagmire. He was spot on but had different motivations for going ahead with GW

@Pand0ro
The issue is that the modern Democratic Party is socialist, they are not even denying it.
To call someone a socialist is not an insult.
Whereas the Republicans are not Fascist at all.
To call someone a fascist is a very serious insult.

Therefore the one is a deliberate smear to demonise a group, the other is a statement of fact.

@Hanno There are some members of the Democratic who are Socialist, a few Communist, many who love this country and consider the agenda of the extreme left as delusional and damaging. There are some members of the Republican party who are fascist in their beliefs, some who are authoritarian and many who are following what they believe to be the best interests of America and love their country. Please don't pack everybody in the same container.

@Pand0ro
Name the fascist Republican members of Congress and Senate.
Name the socialists Democratic members of Congress and Senate.

Go and call someone in the street a fascist and then someone else as socialist...
Look at the responses.

No, it is not the same is it?

19

Don’t kid yourself; they don’t believe it for a second. If Trump really was another Hitler, they’d all be hanging from piano wire in the basement of the DOJ (Renamed Ministry of Patriotism.) And they know it because that’s how they’d handle dissent if they had that power.

They call him Hitler for the same reason they call him and all his supporters bigoted, racist, sexist, homophobic xenophobes. It’s simply how they engage in a debate.

Read Alinsky. He didn’t invent his rules for radicals, but he honed their application through years of street organizing. Never debate issues. Ridicule any opposing ideas. Smear and insult those who hold them. And never get caught in a situation where you might be called upon to actually explain and defend your actions.

The Hitler slur is a trap, and we fall into it every time we try to defend against it. Just look at the ridiculous way this question has been framed. We have to stop letting the left set the terms of the debate. Accusations and slander based on calculated lies are unworthy of a defense. They require retaliation. Hard, fast, brutal pushback.

Nothing is more pathetic than a befuddled conservative protesting, lamely, “I am not Hitler!”

Edgework Level 8 July 26, 2020

Exactly. The question is ridiculous because it focuses on the target of the smear, assuming there are valid “reasons” to smear him, rather than the smear tactic itself.

This is a really good point. I've been looking at this as an inability to debate. But, if this is a strategy or tactic that's really scary.

Also you should never say "I'm not racist" at the beginning of a statement or you've already been locked into their false premises.

7

As mentioned below many on the right accused Obama of being like Hitler. There are plenty of people on the extreme left and extreme right who are crippled by all-or-nothing thinking. To resort to that indicates a deep seated fear of uncertainty where a person feels unanchored if there is. Everything is probability but some things are so highly probable that we treat them as certainty but there is no certainty. This universe would not be here if there were because it needs uncertainty in order to grow.

Trump has not pushed for suppression of religion, ideas and public expression but he has suggested them from time to time. One of the greatest problems is the tendency to lump all the left or all the right into a homogeneous block where every one in them is either all good or all bad. Unwillingness to respect or even listen to the gradation of viewpoints is probably a major reason we are in the situation we are in.

Pand0ro Level 7 July 26, 2020

"Orange man bad" = "Obama man bad" = "Hitler bad" logic perhaps?

@Admin There is no logic to it at all. It is pure emotion. In reading a book about Sigmund Freud it was stated that he had to have a best friend and a greatest enemy. There seem to be many who need an enemy to focus on. When a country is functioning most of them are focused on different countries. In America today it is often our fellow citizens, which is being strongly encouraged by mainly Russia on social media. We have been taught since the 90s that our opponents are evil and want nothing more that to destroy America. It has evolved into profound dislike of politicians and complete loss of faith in government. The original idea was to demonize the opponent to guarantee a vote for the right party. It worked in gaining the votes but is now destroying us.

Write Comment

Recent Visitors 169

Photos 127 More

Posted by Admin Does teaching "white guilt" also cultivate a "white pride" backlash?

Posted by Admin Is it time to take a knee on the Superbowl?

Posted by Admin Why not equality right now?

Posted by Admin How's Biden doing?

Posted by Admin How many good friends do you have from other political tribes?

Posted by Admin What did Trump do, if anything, to incite violence?

Posted by Admin Is free speech dead?

Posted by Admin Is free speech dead?

Posted by Admin Is free speech dead?

Posted by Admin Under what time and circumstance is the use of violence warranted?

Posted by Admin Now what?

Posted by Admin What do you expect to be achieved by this week's pro-Trump DC rally?

Posted by Admin What did you learn in 2020?

Posted by Admin Should pedophiles be allowed to have "child" sex robots?

Posted by Admin Do you have a "line in the sand" regarding political or social change?

Posted by Admin Should big tech firms hire more Blacks and Hispanics?

  • Top tags#video #media #racist #world #biden #truth #government #liberal #racism #democrats #conservatives #society #politics #community #youtube #justice #IDW #hope #friends #videos #Identity #FreeSpeech #Google #book #policy #vote #Police #conservative #evidence #culture #violence #reason #economic #USA #liberals #tech #Socialmedia #money #god #guns #gender #whites #campaign #population #laws #religion #TheTruth #equality #democrat #Christian ...

    Members 9,848Top

    Moderator